Below you can find the Out of pumpkin? tyler florence says you can substitute the butternut type of this in his pumpkin soup Jeopardy Words Answer. The answer to Out of pumpkin? tyler florence says you can substitute the butternut type of this in his pumpkin soup has 6 letters. This clue belongs to the Pumpkin eater category and is part of Jeopardy Word Level 15. If you scroll near the bottom you will find other clues and answers part of level 15